Inductive/Deductive Bible Study

How do we read the Bible?  We can read it with an inductive reasoning mindset or a deductive reasoning mindset.  When you read inductively, you read a passage and from the details you derive some general life principles.  It is a bottom up approach.  When you read deductively, you start with a premise or a theory and you look at a passage to verify (or not) the premise.  It is a top down approach.  There are valid reasons to use both approaches, and there are potential problems with each approach.

When you read the Bible, context is everything.  You can avoid a lot of problems if you put the passage in context.  The Bible is a library of 66 books, written about 2000 to 3500 years ago by about 40 human authors.  Though the Bible was written for us to read, it was written to the people of that time and place.  How did the original hearers understand it?  So there are several questions to ask.  What is the historical context of the passage?  What is the cultural context?  Is it a historical document, a letter, poetry or something else?  What is the context in regard to the surrounding passages?  What is the context to other passages (and books) of the same time period?  And what is the context in relation to the overarching story of Jesus and his work here?  Context is very important!

To understand how those who originally understood it, we also need to know how life was different between then and modern day.  What things are important today that were not important back then, and what are the things important back then that are not important today?  This applies to the cultural context.  One example is today we are very individualistic and back then they were much more family and community oriented.

This sounds overwhelming.   Do not worry.  There are resources available to help you read and study the Bible.  Study Bibles, study guides, and many Christian books are good resources to help you interpret the Bible.  I do make use of them.  They are helpful.  That is why it is good to also learn how Christians in the past have interpreted the Bible for the Holy Spirit has enlightened Christians in the past as he continues to do so today.  The Christian faith, though personal, is a faith that is found in community.  Therefore the biblical understanding  of Christians in the past and the present, under careful scrutiny of Holy Scripture, can be a guide to help you interpret the Bible.  Let us get back to inductive and deductive reasoning.

If you are using the inductive reasoning approach then you need to decide what general theological principles are found in the passage.  Once you have determined the potential theological principles then you need to find other passages to prove that it is a valid theological principle.  (There should also be one passage in the New Testament validating your principle.)   Once validated then you need to put it into practice.  One needs to be careful not to a priori determine the principle or principles.

If you are using the deductive reasoning approach then you need to determine whether the passage fits the premise or topic that you had a priori determined.  Again, are there other passages that fit your topic? (And again there should be one in the New Testament.)  Many times with a deductive Bible study, the topic has been determined by others and you are in a topical Bible study where you are reading a list of passages that should support the topic.  All the passages in context should support the topic.  You need to be careful of the context and your own biases.  

If you want to find something in the Bible to prove your point, there is a good chance that you can find it, but it will most likely not be in context of the surrounding verses or of the Bible in general.  For an extreme example. Charles Manson used the book of Revelation, in particular chapter 9, to promote his violent vision of the future and his use of the Beatles songs.  (The locusts were the Beatles.)  Charles Manson looked at the Bible to authenticate his violent vision.  He found what he was looking for, and by his reasoning deduced his proof.  The problem was that he set out to use the Bible to authenticate his beliefs, and not to discover what the Bible had to say.  His proof passages were out of context and his vision did not fit with the rest of the Bible.  We need to be careful to keep things in context and to be careful to let our reasoning, desires, and feelings not bias how we read the Bible.  There are many other examples of people using the Bible to authenticate their beliefs or viewpoints.  Avoid doing it.

Sometimes people allow tradition, a person’s writings, cultural beliefs, certain moral values, science, or even reason to have the same or higher authority than the Bible.  I believe the Bible is the true and only real authority. Do not discount or water down what the Bible says.  Again, so when studying the Bible, context is important and be aware of your biases.  And have other Christians confirm your interpretation. 

For more information on studying the Bible, check out “Read, Mark, Learn, and Inwardly Digest” and “Is the Bible Wicked?”.

Leave a comment